"Two men got out and met a third person on the side of my house," nearby resident Rich Pacheco told WCBS, "and they went on that property and that's when I called 911."

41-year-old Gabriel DeJesus, who heads Sacred Heart School for the Arts in Mount Vernon, is currently being investigated by the New York Archdiocese. Officials said that he "has been a well-regarded educator," and he was still serving as the school's principal as of Monday.

DeJesus would only say that he "made a mistake" when asked for comment.

UPDATE: DeJesus has been asked to resign.